Dance Like No-one’s Watching – The role of honeybee communication in colony well being
A talk by Lynne Ingrams
Lynne, who is a Master Beekeeper, explored the Why? and How? of the many different forms of communication between bees, how they respond to their environment, and how this affects the ability of the colony to survive and thrive.
The honeybee colony is often referred to as a super-organism, which means an organism consisting of many individual organisms. The term describes a social unit of animals such as honey bees, bumble bees and ants, which have highly organized division of labour, and where individuals are not able to survive by themselves for any length of time.
Why do bees need to communicate?
There may be 60-70,000 bees in a small enclosed space, so there is a need to operate efficiently. There is also a need to respond swiftly to changing threats and opportunities. Ideally, actions need to be coordinated.
Information flow within the bee
The two main systems for communication within the bee are the nervous system and the endocrine system. The nervous system works very quickly with electrical messages passing to and from the brain to other parts of the bee. The endocrine system produces hormones, which are chemical messages. These are produced in cells or glands in one part of the body and affect cells in other parts of the organism. Thus they may be slower to act compared to nerve impulses.
Information flow within the colony
Because of bees’ mobility they can use dance language, trophalaxis and messenger bees to convey information. Bees also produce pheromones that act on other bees through the hive atmosphere (see below). An example would be the sting pheromone which can produce a rapid response.
Division of labour
Queens and drones each have their own jobs in the colony. Workers, however, progress through a series of physiological changes to their bodies as they grow older, enabling them to sequentially act as nest cleaners, larval feeders, queen feeders, honey and nectar processors, wax makers, guards and lastly, foragers. This provides flexibility and a rapid response to changing situations.
How do bees respond to changes around them?
The colony relies on indirect stimulae of the shared environment and will respond accordingly. Thus if the temperature rises to a dangerous level more bees will be recruited to forage for water. Cold weather will produce a clustering response to protect the brood.
Lynne talked about the ‘technologies’ available to the bees within the superorganism. Thus scout bees recruiting house bees to a good nectar-producing flower will use dances, trophalaxis, antennation, vibration and scent. During swarming they will use pheromones, dances, vibration and piping.
Probably the best known is the scent of the queen which promotes colony cohesion. Workers produce Nasanov pheromone, the ‘come hither’ signal, and the alarm pheromone meaning ‘come and help’. Drones produce their own pheromone used in DCAs and worker brood pheromone inhibits development of worker ovaries as well as stimulating pollen collection.
Collection of nectar, pollen and water needs to be an efficient, coordinated operation with appropriate division of labour between foragers and storers/receivers. Nectar, for example, is supply driven. Ease of unloading back at the hive dictates what happens next. Too long (50 sec+), and the forager will do a tremble dance to recruit more receivers. A very quick response (less than 20 sec) and the forager will perform a waggle dance to recruit more foragers. An intermediate response time will produce a return to foraging.
There is also a stop signal used to decrease recruitment of foragers when it takes too long to unload. The returning bee will head butt waggle dancers and ‘pipe’, causing them to ‘freeze’. Watch out for this behaviour in your hives!
Another interesting behaviour you might see is the dorso-ventral abdominal vibration or DVAV. This signal is used to recruit non-foragers to forage when there is a long period of flow or a new flow after a dearth. New recruits either go to the dance floor to watch waggle dancers or fly direct to the forage if previously visited.
Pollen regulation within the colony is demand driven. Nurse bees consume pollen and produce protein rich food for foragers. A plentiful supply of high protein quality will tend to inhibit pollen collection whereas fewer feeds or lower protein quality will tend to stimulate pollen collection.
Water regulation is also demand driven, for example when temperatures are high. The response is to recruit unemployed foragers to increase water collection without affecting nectar collection.
Communication within swarming
On the day of the swarm the workers are prompted by a piping signal to warm their wing muscles in the last hour before setting off. Just before setting off, the colony is activated into flight by a few bees performing buzzing runs in the hive. The swarm then settles into a cluster nearby to check they still have the queen, detectable by her pheromones. Nest site selection is arrived at by competing waggle dancers and when consensus is reached the colony lifts off with more piping signals and the scout bees guide the mass by buzzing runs through the moving swarm to the new nest. Finally, bees will be seen at the entrance fanning Nasanov pheromone to guide the stragglers in.
There are many more ways in which bees communicate and probably just as many that we have yet to learn about!
Lynne gave two references:
The Super-organism – Bert Hölldobler & E.O.Wilson
The Wisdom of the Hive – Tom Seeley
Report of March meeting 2019 – A talk by Brigit Strawbridge
Bees: Importance of diversity and relationships with flowering plants
Brigit began by saying she intended covering ALL bees, not just honey bees, as well as other pollinators, in order to show the importance of diversity in plant ↔ bee relationships.
To put things in perspective there are roughly:
320,000 flowering plant species worldwide,
more than 300,000 pollinating animal species
and 25,000 bee species.
In the UK our pollinators include:
59 butterfly species,
4,000 beetles and
270 species of bees.
The importance of bees became apparent when Brigit explained that about a third of our food and beverage producing plants are pollinated by bees and that up to 80% of flowering plants are dependent on bees for reproduction. No wonder that bees are regarded as a key ‘indicator species’. The knock on effect of anything affecting bees will soon be felt in the rest of the environment.
What is a bee?
From Brigit’s photos we learned that bees range in size from Wallace’s giant bee (Megachile pluto), about 38mm long, to a tiny solitary bee the size of a midge! Worker bumble bees in the UK can be up to 24mm.
Briefly, the life cycle of a bumble bee starts with the emergence of the fertilised queen in the spring. She feeds on nectar and starts building a nest. She provides pollen and nectar for the developing young workers who will take over the duties of colony maintenance, leaving the queen free to concentrate on egg laying. Later in the year the queen lays drone eggs instead of worker eggs, followed by fertile female eggs. The males leave the nest and move to other areas while the queens mate and find a crevice to hibernate over winter.
Causes of bee decline in recent years can be largely attributed to habitat loss and pesticides. Further damage is being caused by climate change, invasion by non-native species and pollution. All of these effects reduce biodiversity and the ability of ecosystems to survive and thrive.
Cross pollination is the key to diversity of the flowering plants which have been evolving alongside the insect world for the last few tens of millions of years. So we see a range of characteristics in bees enabling them to take advantage of the numerous niches in the plant world. UK bumble bees, for example, have a proboscis length of 15-20mm whereas the honey bee proboscis is only 6mm.
Pollen collection methods vary between species. We are familiar with the pollen baskets of honey bees but red mason bees will ‘buzz’ on a flower to dislodge pollen, which sticks to the hairs on its abdomen, called the scopa. Sometimes, if the proboscis is not long enough, buff tailed bumble bees will cut a hole in the corolla to reach nectar and pollen, a process called larceny.
98% of wild flower meadows have disappeared in the last century.
Neonicotinoids persist in the environment and pass into the soil and water courses. From here they are reabsorbed into plants, pass into nectar and pollen, and end up affecting pollinators. The toxic mix of pesticides and fungicides affects the ability of bees to ferment bee bread which is essential to their existence.
What can we do?
Don’t tidy your garden too much. Leave heaps of ‘rubbish’ for bees to nest in.
Make or buy ‘Bee Hotels’. Keep them clean.
Plant for a succession of flowering plants all through the year. Brigit’s list plus a few extras – mahonia, crocus, aconite, celandine, snowdrops, hellebores, dandelion, flowering currant, pulmonaria, vipers bugloss, nepeta, borage, wild marjoram, Michaelmas daisies, sedum, ivy, heathers.
Don’t forget the trees and shrubs – viburnum , mimosa, camellias, sarcococca, skimmia.
Plant wild flower seed mixes for meadows if you have room.
Recommended reference books:
Field Guide to the Bees of Great Britain and Ireland – Steven Falk
Plants for Bees – Kirk and Howes (available to East Devon members from the branch library)
The selfish case for saving bees: it’s how to save ourselves
These crucial pollinators keep our world alive. Yes, they are under threat – but all is not lost. Click here to read the article.
Outbreak of EFB reported
An outbreak of EFB has been reported by one of our members about ‘5km east of Hawkchurch’. If you live in the area and are not yet on BeeBase we would recommend you go to the BeeBase website as soon as possible to register. This will ensure you are informed of any threats in your area.
World’s largest bumblebee under threat.
The Patagonian bumblebee, the worlds largest bumblebee, is under threat from the import of species native to Europe.The growth of the bumblebee trade for agricultural pollination since the 1980s has been identified as one of the top emerging environmental issues likely to affect global diversity.Follow this link to read the article.
Best plants for bees: 5 yr study results by RosyBee
Follow the link to see the results of 5 years of monitoring which bees visit a variety of ‘bee-friendly’ plants. http://www.rosybee.com/research
World’s largest bee, missing for 38 years, found in Indonesia
What’s that Buzz? Plants hear when bees are coming New research has shown that plants can ‘hear’ sounds around them and flowers respond to the buzz of approaching bees by producing sweeter nectar. The research biologists from Tel Aviv University played recordings of flying bee sounds to evening primrose flowers and found that after a few minutes the sugar concentration in the flower’s nectar had increased by 20% on average when compared with flowers left in silence or submitted to higher pitched sounds.
The authors of the report say that, for the first time, they have shown plants can rapidly respond to pollinator sounds in an ecologically relevant way.
Producing sweeter nectar in response to the sounds of bees can help entice the insects to visit the flowers and increase the chances of its pollen being distributed.
Thanks to Ann P. for spotting this article in the Times.
Scientists sew trackers to Asian Hornets to find and destroy nests before they kill honeybees
Britain’s beekeepers are turning to technology to prevent aggressive Asian hornets destroying their colonies. In a first successful trial, experts at the University of Exeter attached tracking devices to the backs of the voracious hornets and then followed them back to their nests.
Asian hornet information
The June edition of the BBKA News has extensive information about the Asian hornet threat. In particular, pages 209 and 210 have full colour reproductions of the Asian hornet alert document issued by the Non Native Species Secretariat (NNSS) for you to cut out and use as your personal guide to identification of this invasive species.