EDBK Annual General Meeting
Held at Kilmington Village Hall on Thursday 5th November 2026
The AGM was efficiently run as all the reports had been circulated beforehand.
Election of President, Officers and Committee for 2026/27
A big thank you to the members who attended the AGM and voted in your new Committee.
| President | Hilary Kirkcaldie |
| Chair | Nigel Boulton |
| Treasurer | Andy Potter |
| Secretary | Rhiannon Hodson |
| Committee members | John Badley, Mary Boulton, Marion Coleman, Ralph Cox, Bob Muckett, Nick Silver, Stan Wroe |
| Delegate to the Devon EC | Nigel Boulton |
This year seven members of EDBK took the BBKA basic assessment, all of whom achieved a pass with credit or a distinction. They were presented with their Certificates of Proficiency in Apiculture by our President Hilary Kirkcaldie. Congratulations to all of you! Beatrix Silvano was the winner of the Craythorne Cup, for achieving highest marks in the group. Andrew Bartlett was presented with his Module 1 (Honey bee management with credit) and Module 3 (Honey bee pests, diseases and poisoning) certificates. Nigel Boulton was presented with his Module 1 (Honey bee management with credit) and Module 2 (Honey bee products and forage) Certificates.
Some of the certificate winners
The 2026 AGM marks a turning point in the running of the Branch. The three core members of the committee, Chair, Treasurer and Secretary, stood down after accumulating a total of 21 years of service.
Alasdair wrote in his final Chairman’s Report:
I leave the chair knowing that EDBK is in great shape, in no small measure to our fabulous bee shed hub. I would be remiss if I didn’t extend a heartfelt thanks to Bill and Jenny for their continued patronage and support. Also, I must say a huge thank you to my committee, especially Val and Keith. They have all been a huge source of strength and help, particularly through the difficult days of COVID, so this goes to everyone past and present.
Val wrote:
Finally, at this AGM I take my leave as your branch secretary. This has been a decision not taken lightly. Eleven years in the role have brought me into contact with so many lovely members and lifetime friendships have been forged. That would not have happened without EDBK. Time though to be put out to pasture. Thank you to those who have answered rallying calls to do this that or the other in support of the branch. Thank you too from my lap top which is ageing fast, needs an overhaul and is gratefully retiring after writing 132 Buzzmails, 51 committee meeting minutes and countless response emails.
Keith said:
This will be my final Treasurer’s Report after 14 years, so thanks to all who have made my role so easy and straightforward. I shall miss the constant attention to the figures and all the lovely people I have met both here and across all branches in Devon.
Bob Muckett, Apiary Manager, outlined the achievements of the apiary team over the past year. These include limiting the number colonies to a maximum of 12, still sufficient for a teaching apiary, taking off 118kg of honey, some of which was used to run the honey extraction day for the Beginners, as well as to provide income for the Branch. Preparations are in hand to plan defences at the apiary against the YLAH, when it arrives in our area. Finally, Bob gave a word of praise to both the apiary team and the Grounds maintenance team for their hard work and dedication over the past season.
After refreshments, Richard Simpson gave a resume of the results from the DARG Bait Hive trials which took place earlier this year.
Richard reminded us that Tom Seeley’s book, Honey Bee Democracy, based on his extensive work on nest cavity volumes, answered a lot of questions on this topic but still left some questions unanswered. Trying to answer these questions is the reason for the present trial.
Two basic questions were posed at the inception of the trial:
- Is there a best size for a bait hive (in the UK)?
- Is there a correlation between the size of the bait hive and the size of the swarm?
While collecting this data, additional questions were put in order to fill out the picture:
- Does the swarm size vary throughout the season?
- Does the origin affect the swarm size?
- What is the relationship between scouting and adoption?
- Is there a preferred orientation?
- Are some hive materials better than others?
The Trial
The trial started on 22nd March and ended on 12th July 2026.
There were 122 participants providing 412 bait hives.
Every bait hive had a different registration number plus the hive details (volume, type, materials, orientation, owner, location).
At only 19% adoption rate, 2026 seems to have been a poor swarm year, confirmed by general experience, but that just means there was a smaller adoption rate than wished for.
Organisation
The trial required organising a number of steps:
- Recruit participants.
- Standardise the offers by including swarm lure in every hive.
- Write the protocol.
- Administration phase, including reminders and updates, supplying lure and answering queries.
- Data capture, analysis and report.
So how did it go?


As the bar chart above shows, there was a slow start but things improved by week 4 (w/c 12th April). At week 10 (w/c 24th April May) swarming seemed to stop abruptly. This was probably due to adverse weather conditions. Activity picked up over the remaining weeks and finally faded away by week 16 (w/c 5th July).
Week 8 (w/c 10th May) had the highest number of swarms per week (14), and week 13 (w/c 14th June) achieved 10 swarms, the second highest weekly total. The numbers indicate the majority of large swarms (blue bars) occurred in the early weeks of the trial, while the majority of small swarms (green bars) occurred in the later weeks. The implication is that beekeepers need to put bait hives out early to catch prime swarms. Later swarms are predominantly small, probably casts. While that doesn’t make them useless, it does require different handling as winter approaches.
Results
The graph below shows the number of swarms in each volume category (blue line). As expected, there is a maximum at the 30-40 litre mark.

However, when the results are calculated as a percentage of the hives on offer at each volume category, a second peak shows up at around 80 litres (green line). Richard felt this good enough reason to repeat the trial using just two volumes, approximately 40 and 80 litres.

The graph of Swarms and Scouts by trial week indicates a peak at week 5 (w/c 19th April), a second peak at week 8 (w/c 10th May), with an almost complete cessation of scouting during week 10 (w/c 24th April).

Further analysis of scouting behaviour is shown in the graph below. The entrance orientation of the bait hives is plotted for two situations: scouted and adopted vs scouted and rejected. There is a clear preference here.

What conclusions can we make?
| Question | Answer |
| Is there a relationship between the size of bait hive and the size of swarm? | Probably No, subject to the size being broadly acceptable but… |
| Does the swarm size vary throughout the season? | YES |
| Does the origin affect the swarm size? | YES |
| What is the relationship between scouting and adoption? | Average 7:1 (Max 20:1, Wk5) |
| Is there a preferred orientation? | YES |
| Are some hive materials better than others? | NO |
| Is there a best size for a bait hive (in the UK)? | The results show two possible ‘best sizes’, the expected peak at 30-40 litres plus a second peak at 80-90 litres. |
So, watch this space, and possibly prepare bait hives at 80 to 90 litres for another trial next year!
Our thanks to Richard for giving us an insight into how swarms choose their new home.
To read the original report of the trial, go to https://dargbees.org/